MEET THE MAILERS
Meet The Mailers: Relevancy, Personalization, & Creativity
In this episode, we talked with XMPie about how personalization increases the value that printers can add to their customers’ mail (and other channels).
In this episode, I chatted with David Baldaro, Marketing Manager at XMPie. XMPie is a software development company that provides personalized, multichannel variable data publishing (VDP) and marketing automation solutions and is headquartered in New York, NY.
We talked about how using data creatively builds stronger customer connections:
“I can use that data to drive relevancy into the copy, the imagery, the layout, the timing, the media that I use, the pieces that I pull together.”
David Baldaro
Marketing Manager,
XMPie
Among the many topics we covered in our lengthy talk:
- Dave’s background in print
- What XMPie does & plugs into Adobe InDesign
- Personalization that connects with customers
- Balancing relevancy vs. privacy when using data
- How printers can get started on personalizing mail
Here are some questions and answers from our conversation (edited for clarity and space):
- [C]an you give a quick rundown of what XMPie is, what it does, how it connects all these different tasks into a single workflow?
So we sell software into organizations, predominantly into the print market space. But XMPie is all about personalization. It’s all about omnichannel, but print. But it’s all about doing everything “one to one in one”, which is our tagline. [I]t’s a single platform where everything then resonates out from the center which exists where data is. So whether it’s personalized print, whether that’s omnichannel communication for websites, emails, videos, imagery, whether that’s e-commerce, web-to-print stores or in-plant, print procurement stores, XMPie has facilities and platforms and facets of the software platform that allow our customers to essentially add more value, make more money, drive more print, across all three of those core sections.
- And so you have a direct plug-in into the Adobe Suite and InDesign?
Yeah. So it’s probably one of the big USPs behind XMPie … And essentially the mantra, the positioning for XMPie hasn’t changed dramatically across 2 decades, which is about driving things creatively, about driving personalization in a very creative manner, separately through print and through digital. So in order to do that, we move away from programmatical, like programmed variable data, and we enable designers and the content makers to have control. So yes, you mentioned it there, they have a plugin for Adobe InDesign, a native plugin. So any designer can pick up XMPie and start weaving personalization and dynamic elements into their design without needing to touch programming or get into the nitty gritty, it’s plug and play, but more importantly there, it’s all about efficiency and production. So what you’re creating, you know you’re not going to turn your very expensive high-end digital press into a slow desktop printer. We’re driving it at rated speed with efficiencies built in. We’re then driving volume as well as scale and high level of personalization.
[W]e’re using AI in different ways. [W]e’re using AI ourselves to help our customers. We’re baking AI into the customer support and the side that a customer sees in answering questions and getting understanding and knowledge as to “how do I do something”. We’re using AI in the product itself. So enabling AI asset generation, AI questions and answering. So we’re racing to do it. We’re doing it responsibly. We’re doing it maturely. But then part of my job is using AI to help augment everything XMPie can do. So how can I use XMPie and AI together to create something better of the two pieces separately.- [W]hat’s the difference between personalization that genuinely connects with somebody and personalization which just kind of changes a name or an image or an offer? Do you really need a lot of data to make a mail piece or another piece of print feel personal and relevant?
So the latter part, do you need a lot of data? No, you don’t. And I think this is where AI is helping us because I can use what data I do have and AI together to help create and augment additional data that I can then use as part of the piece. If I know your demographic or your age or your past purchases, I can use AI to help augment and create additional knowledge around you that I can then use in the direct mail piece. So there’s that side to it. Ultimately, I don’t need a lot of data. I just need some data I can use intelligently within the piece.
So to come back to the other part of this, personalization, or real personalization, I sort of compare it to what is mail merge and what is a good piece of personalized communication. And I think even then, we as consumers expect personalization now. You go back 5 years ago, 10 years ago, you didn’t always say it was “Dear Homeowner”… It was very generic and that was OK. But then marketers wanted to get more specific and more personalized. So it said “Hey Dave”, “Hey Paul”.
Now I think we almost expect that level of communication from brands that we are engaging with. If you don’t know who I am and you refer to me as “Homeowner”, you do not have my attention. So I’m expecting you to at least address your communications to me in a personal way. I think that level of mail merge has now become, it needs to be the norm. Which means that we’ve now got to take a step up. Now I have to use the data in a more productive way. And I think we move from having personalization to being more relevant. The data that I use and the piece that I position to you has to be relevant. The content has to be relevant. The timing has to be relevant. The offers have to be relevant. The personalization is expected. Relevancy now becomes the king and relevancy is driven again from the data.
- How can printers move beyond quoting price per piece and really start selling business results that their work can deliver?
If I can have the value conversation …well, your database is 30,000 people. Do you really need to send that 30,000 people? Have you checked your data? Have you cleansed it? Have you validated it? What data do you have? How can we use that in a relevant way to create a creative piece? Do you have designers on board? So once you start opening this conversation up, then I think you can add value. And then when you understand the value of the piece, maybe you don’t need to print 30,000. Maybe you only really need to print 5,000 to the highest population of that list because that’s where you want the value from … But by understanding it, do you then drive the value? Drive the value, then you’re going to have repeat business because you become a trusted advisor, you become linked, you become someone your customer is going to come back to.
- Yeah, I think that points out, marketers are concerned about budgets and where they should focus. And I think that’s a great opportunity to talk about that, about the list they’re using, refining their segmentation, and where they’re going to use that personalization or not.
Absolutely. With marketing budgets as they are, and the fight for attention that is always happening in the land of consumers, you have to look at the why. You have to look at the “how best can I help my client deliver this?” Because that’s where your value is going to come from. What we see inside XMPie is that companies that have XMPie are quick to deliver. Because it’s a creative piece, if I’ve got a customer that’s come into the shop and says “look, here’s my data, here’s my ideas, what can you do?” If I’m going to go away and spend like 3,4 months to try and create something or a week to try and create something, I’ve already missed the boat. If I can quickly turn around a design prototype and start moving this forward, then I can become responsive. Then I can start to get involved in the conversation quicker and deliver the value on top of it.
- When you have direct mail, you can attract attention with that piece, but then you have to move the recipient’s journey, which can include QR code, personalized landing page, email, other digital channels along the way. How can printers help customers connect all those touchpoints and understand where mail’s contribution is to that customer experience?
I think it’s never been more possible than it has ever been to have this conversation because today more than ever, the technological barriers don’t exist as they existed like 10 years ago, which are only like resource and skill sets. And I had to understand this stuff. I’m a printer, I know how to print. I know how to drive my press to the fastest capability with the best stock, with the best quality. I think now we’re in a marketplace where everything is possible. And I think given the tool set from XMPie in being able to link physical communication in the same way as digital.
Now, what I mean by that is that I’m not doing a digital piece, let’s say …an email piece that’s to go with the direct mail piece separately. I’m not splitting the data and trying to do it in two different ways, which I can do. But it’s siloed, absolutely. Which means that if something happens over here, it’s not repeated over here. Or if something changes over here, it’s not over [here]. So by doing that, I can do it, but it’s a very dangerous pathway to go down. Because XMPie is this one-to-one in one and the data is integral and the business rules are integral. And that then feeds out to the design, whether it’s an email or an InDesign piece or a direct mail piece or a webpage. Because that’s done from a single source of truth, it means that actually if I’ve got this customer and they want to put out this piece, I can drive the value for the print to say “hey, I can now make the print more responsive for you”.
But the same way, I can now start to build in additional pieces of media. because as consumers, one piece is OK. If I send 30,000 spray-and-pray-type pieces, I’m going to get a response. It’s going to be small. If I then start including personalization into that and dynamic and make it relevant, I’m going to increase my response rates. If I then maybe add an email piece into that as well, so at the same time as the print piece going out …, I’m going to increase my response rates even more. If I add a QR code to the print piece … So every piece of additional communication that I then add into that campaign is going to only help to increase the response rates and the connections that I have with my consumers, thus drive my value.
And this is where XMPie helps because it’s always been incredibly easy to bring all those additional pieces of communication into the same piece using exactly the same data.
- I like reading a lot of consumer surveys about marketing and mail and personalization and data. And it comes up often that consumers want mail that’s for them and knows them, but at the same time, they don’t want to feel uncomfortable with somebody knowing too much about them. How should brands balance useful personalization, however that’s defined, with trust and not cross a line or be creepy?
It’s a good question. And it’s like I’ve said a few times, just because you can doesn’t mean you should. Just because you can and you have access to the data that I know, Bob, you went into the store on the 21st of July. You brought this product for this particular price. You walked out. I know everything about you, but just because I do doesn’t mean I need to shout about it. I think this is that line that says, data needs to be translated into value. And I need to look at you as a consumer and say, what’s going to drive you to make the decision that I want you to do? What’s going to drive you to click on the link and come back in and purchase more product … to subscribe for another year? What’s going to help you take you past that line? And it’s not going to be, in-your-face personalization like that has that trigger creepy effect to it that says, OK, I know I did it, but you telling me this just helps make it a little bit weird and it’s going to freak me out.
[T]hat’s where you need to turn personalization into relevancy. I can use that data to drive relevancy into the copy, the imagery, the layout, the timing, the media that I use, the pieces that I pull together. I can help use the data to drive the relevancy and then to connect with you as a consumer and pull you along that process. If I just use the data out-of-the-box, I think you’ll hit that creepy-esque-like barrier quite quickly because there’s no thought behind it. As consumers, when we, I think this is part of the whole AI conversation as well, when something comes across to AI or too false or too unthought about, you lose my trust as a consumer. When it’s interweaved and becomes relevant and I don’t necessarily see it in front of me, then it becomes subconscious. And then I’m along to the journey, because it’s actually relevant and I’m vibing with it and I’m going with it.So actually, this is interesting. [T]here’s no hard and fast answer here. It comes down to the brands, the job, the piece, the customer, the demographic. Because again, you might talk to a Gen Z in a very different way and we’re using different media than you might a millennial or a Gen X. [B]ut there’s no reason why you can’t use the same data and then split it different ways. So actually the tone of voice that I have, because I know you’re a millennial or in that demographic is going to be different than if I know that you’re a Gen X or you’re a Boomer. I can start to use it to tailor that piece in more ways than just changing the data.
- So, thinking about that value-driven mail and what printers should be doing, what is one or two things that a printer should get started on to providing value with personalization in mail?
I think if I were starting out again or I was starting in the print industry as a printer, I think I would look internally myself. And again, I give this advice to a lot of XMPie users to say “hey, your first sale shouldn’t be external. It should be internal.” If you can’t use the software yourself to go and get customers and to help drive your business, then how are you expecting me to trust that you’re going to do it for my business? And I think we’ve seen, certainly I’ve seen our customers do this time and time again, where they use XMPie’s tools, to ask themselves the question “well, how can I get more customers? How can I get more customers to come back and repeat buy or get new customers in the door?” So they’re using the tools to do that. But I think it’s a case of looking at the data that you have, whether it’s an internal CRM system you’ve got, whether it’s an external client and go “OK, well, how can I add value? How can I use this data in a creative way to engage with the customers that I need to? And how can I drive them through to a call-to-action that I want them to take?” [I]t doesn’t have to be massive, doesn’t have to be huge, doesn’t have to be hundreds of thousands.
You know, I’ve seen some campaigns and again, you mentioned it before, the car dealership. It was a small campaign. It was just like an event piece. But the print service provider at the time almost like I attacked it as a paying per thousand type conversation, or you need like, this many invitations, you need this many emails, this many web pages, this many like point-of-sale pieces. And that’s how they did it, which is fine, but when they sat down and they pulled the results in, and my sitting down with the company director, he’s walking me through your slide deck, and it’s like a 30 point 30-slide deck is to all the things that he’s put together. And he says, “David, I’ve really struggled to like pay the price of this because it was all like disparate things.” I know it’s like the second to last slide, Paul, I think it was, where he said, we actually summarized all the findings. And he said, look, the cost wise, and this is what we charged them, and this is what they did, this is what we charged them, and this is what they sold on the day because the whole event was to try and sell cars.
So we sold X number of cars and we charged them X thousand dollars. And I said “hold on, that means that they paid you just over a hundred dollars per sale.” They said “well, yeah, I suppose so.” I was like “OK, forget the other 19 slides that came before this point. This is your first slide. This is now your value proposition that, hey, any Mr. Car dealership, would you like me to facilitate you selling cars at a hundred bucks a pop, because if you can, I can repeat the process that I did before. And by the way, I’m going to charge you 200 bucks because now I know I can do it.”
I think that understanding the value internally helps you go and drive this forward and you can build it at scale. And again, that’s one of the propositions by XMPie, that you don’t have to have everything. You can just componentize this and build your business on the back of this. Maybe starting with VDP, growing to web-to-print, growing to cross media omnichannel. It’s a journey and it should be seen as a journey and it should be something that you build upon and understand at each point because you’ve got to go in and sell this.
Here is our conversation (with all questions and answers). We’ve added timecodes for your convenience.
Thank you very much, Lisa, for sharing your perspective and your expertise! To learn more about XMPie, visit their website at XMPie.com.
Your comments and ideas are very important to us in making your Who’s Mailing What! experience even better for you. Through these engaging talks, we hope you’ll take away practical tips, insights, and personal stories to inspire and build your own success.
If you have any feedback — or are interested in sharing your story and viewpoint with our wide and diverse audience on “Meet the Mailers” — please reach out to me. I’d love to hear from you!







